It goes without saying that Batman #5 is the best issue yet of Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo’s run on the comic. I must look like a total pushover with a reviewer, as I started with gushing praise for Batman #1, and have had to stretch to new heights of hyperbole for each subsequent instalment. But more than that, Batman #5 is in my opinion the best comic from any title to be released by DC since the relaunch, and could very well be one of the best single issues of a Batman story I’ve ever read as a new-release floppy. This is the comic I’d hand to people, not just to win them over on trying the relaunched Batman series, but to comic fans who think stories with major superheroes like Batman can’t match creator-owned or indie titles for creativity and ambition, or even to comic cynics who think Batman is just for kids. In short, Batman #5 blew me away.
To offer a catch-up on the plot, last issue ended with Batman’s investigation into the Court of Owls – a shady organisation that could be tied into the very fabric of Gotham since the earliest days of its history – leading him to the sewers of Gotham, where he was ambushed by the Talon (the Court’s mysterious assassin) and dropped into an underground labyrinth. As we begin this issue, Batman has been trapped in said labyrinth for over a week, with no food and only water that is probably drugged for him to drink, with no escape in sight. And he’s starting to lose his mind.
In my review for issue #4, I talked a little about how Capullo’s art was showing touches of horror amidst the classic superhero action. Well, here, we’re taken right over the edge of that cliff, as Snyder gives us a story that is pure horror, arguably scarier than anything he’s written for Swamp Thing or American Vampire. Snyder has talked about horrors such as Jacob’s Ladder and The Shining acting as inspirations for this issue’s script (in particular, there is a truly horrific sequence that owes a lot to the latter’s notorious “Room 217” scene), but what Batman’s twisted journey through the labyrinth most reminded me of was the terrifying conclusion to Twin Peaks, the extended sequence with Dale Cooper in the Black Lodge. “The owls are not what they seem,” indeed. Both tap into that primal fear, that common nightmare of being lost in a strange place, getting increasingly panicked as every attempt to get out takes you back to where you were before…. and you realise you’re not alone, that’s something’s in there with you, chasing you.
This setup alone would be chilling enough, but I think it’s all the more unsettling in that the victim is as beloved a pop culture icon as Batman. This is Batman, who can get out of anything with prep time, the ultimate escape artist, who Grant Morrison triumphantly showed us is capable of outwitting the greatest of masterminds and even coming back from apparent death and a journey through time unscathed! We’ve seen him lured into so many death-traps that it’s old hat, that we see it as little more than a mild inconvenience for him. Snyder gleefully erodes that notion, letting us see Batman struggle to apply that famous logic to his situation, only for it to slip through his fingers and for him to descend into hysteria. As the chapter progresses, it becomes increasingly clear that Batman is acting like a crazy person. And it’s upsetting! Seeing Batman ranting and raving, screaming and sobbing, tearing at his flesh and digging his fingers into the floor… it almost feels like it shouldn’t be allowed. But by dancing on the fringes of what you can get away with in a mainstream superhero property – capped off with a truly shocking cliffhanger – Snyder has injected a sense of genuine “how’s he gonna get out of this!?” peril into a genre that is too often accused of predictability.
Though the bulk of the issue takes place within the labyrinth, acting as an enthralling character dissection of Batman, we do get brief bookends showing how his absence his affecting the supporting cast. I enjoyed this glimpse of the wider Batman universe, particularly the use of Robin, capturing Damian’s pomposity, but also showing the vulnerability of a child whose lost his father.
Snyder has claimed that he feels this could be the best comic script he’s ever written, and I might be inclined to agree with him. For some time now, I’ve come to take Snyder’s name on a book as a guarantee of quality, but here he takes his storytelling to a whole new level, and years from now I imagine people will still be ranking this amongst his best work. This is Snyder’s “Anatomy Lesson”.
Capullo also ups his game, giving us some of the most innovative, experimental visuals I’ve seen in a comic in quite some time. As Batman’s mind fractures, and he’s plagued by ever more nightmarish visions, that sense of the very fabric of reality coming apart is enhanced by the artwork. The pages twist and turn from portrait layout to landscape, and eventually spinning upside down, forcing us to abruptly start reading from right-to-left. We’re left as dizzy and disoriented as Batman. And look at how the page layouts steadily dissolve from neat, regimented grids to haywire, crooked little windows crammed into the page. This is a visual representation of going mad.
I love the way Capullo draws Batman here too. One small touch – the visor on one side of his mask being broken, exposing his eye – speaks volumes throughout the issue. Firstly, it’s a humanising factor, showing us the man, the Bruce Wayne behind the Batman mask, the vulnerable human in this situation. But as the story progresses, that eye gets more dilated, more bloodshot. When Snyder’s script has Batman’s voiceover announcing that he is in control, that he can defeat this enemy, that wild, frantic eye makes a liar out of him. Capullo also makes creepy physical alterations to Batman. Subtle at first, with his cape shifting and changing size and shape from panel to panel. But by the end sequence, we descend from Lynchian horror of the mind to wince-inducing Cronenbergian body horror. Capullo’s been doing superstar work since issue #1, but issue #5 could be his best showcase yet.
The team of inker Jonathan Glapion and colorist FCO have lots to do as well. There is a reversed dynamic at work here, where its the darkness that offers safety and shelter, and harsh, blinding light where the horrors await. And it’s through the efforts of these two that this works so well. The light really does feel harsh, the colors saturated under it. Moments like the scene with the minature city really make you appreciate what an atmospheric, textured comic this is.
Batman #5 is a triumph on every level, with the whole creative team delivering astounding work. If you haven’t been reading Batman, this is where you should jump on, and even if you have no plans of reading Batman monthly, I’d recommend buying this issue in particular, as I imagine it’s going to become a hot commodity before long. If you have been reading Batman, you should feel vindicated. I’ve been enjoying this title immensely, and I already said with last issue that it has become my favourite DC book. And yes, I’m aware it’s been widely critically acclaimed. But I’ve also seen quite a bit of, “Not quite as good as The Black Mirror, but…” type comments. This was in positive reviews, and it’s fair enough, as The Black Mirror has already entered the canon of all-time classic Batman stories.
With Batman #5, this story has now topped The Black Mirror. If Snyder can keep up the quality, we’re looking at another all-time classic. I’m expecting Batman #6 to finally break this streak of this title constantly outdoing itself, because I genuinely think you can’t top a comic as good as Batman #5. But all the same, I expect it to be great, and the third week of February can’t come fast enough.